e-Ariana - Todays Afghan News
 Home 
 News 
 Articles 
 Cartoons 
 Feedback 
 Opinion  
 Contact Us  
 An Ariana Media Publication 09/03/2010
 Afghanistan's Ralph Nader? Inside the Tent of an Honest Man

The New Internationalist
06/09/2009
By Zuhra Bahman

[Printer Friendly Version]

Among the no-chancers in Afghanistan's presidential race there’s one who is attracting attention: Ramazan Bashardost, Afghanistan’s answer to Ralph Nader. Bashardost has built a reputation as a staunch idealist who resigned from his ministerial position in the Karzai government. And he is popular with ordinary Afghans

There are 44 candidates in the upcoming Afghan presidential elections. The list, published last week by the Independent Election Commission of Afghanistan, includes: people who were part of the pro-Soviet Afghan Communist regime of the 1970s and 1980s; people were active in the 1990s Afghan civil war; ex-Taliban member Mullah Rocketi; and several disillusioned members of the current government.

The list is long but it could have been longer had certain others – including charmless ex-Minister of Interior Jalali or chameleon ex-Minister of Finance Ahadi or the semi-literate Governor of Jalalabad, Gul Agha Sherzoi – gone ahead with nominating themselves. There was a collective sigh of relief when these names didn’t make it to the list!

Three on the list do have a real chance: the incumbent President Karzai, former Foreign Minister Dr Abdullah and former Finance Minister Dr Ghani. The rest, with miniscule chances of winning, are using their candidacy to promote themselves in anticipation of getting a ministerial position in the new government or to raise awareness of certain policy issues.

Of the no-chancers there’s one who is attracting attention: Ramazan Bashardost, Afghanistan’s answer to Ralph Nader. Last week I saw his website. It consists of campaign material in a variety of languages aimed at showing him above the ethnic divisions in the country, a range of his educational certificates to show his transparency and competency, and a variety of statements, one-liners and press-releases showcasing his campaign platform.

Bashardost has built a reputation as a staunch idealist who resigned from his ministerial position in the Karzai government. He is popular with ordinary Afghans – he won a parliamentary seat with the second highest number of votes cast for an Afghan MP. Most important, he’s known as an eccentric who travels on a bike with no security, votes against almost any decision that comes to Parliament and receives his guests in a tent.

Intrigued, I called the number on his website. He answered the phone himself and invited me to see him in his tent on Friday before the prayers. I wasn’t sure why I was meeting him; I have already made up my mind who I’m voting for.

I took a taxi to his tent. I wasn’t sure how to give the address to the driver so I just asked him if he knew where the Bashardost tent was. He not only knew about the tent but he was all ready to vote for Bashardost ‘because he is the only one that seems honest; the rest are all thieves’.

In contrast to the heavily guarded Afghan Parliament building across the road, Bashardost’s tent had no guards. The interior was adorned with handmade colourful posters urging people to register to vote – and then vote for Bashardost. I arrived early and sitting on a plastic chair, surveyed his campaign posters. They showed a dove –signifying peace; hands shaking – signifying friendship; a plate of rice – signifying prosperity. And there were a few words from the Quran to show the candidate’s beliefs.

At 10 o’clock sharp Bashardost enters the tent. He’s a slim man, dressed in lightweight, white Afghan cloths that seem to have seen more than their share of washes. He is carrying a pile of folders, notebooks and a diary. He extends his hand towards me and starts talking.

He is not eccentric, I conclude, after listening to him for a few minutes. What he says is what most Afghans want. He says that the US is in Afghanistan due to self interest, but that, he says, is not necessarily a bad thing. It’s up to Afghans to ensure that they use the attention they are getting from the international community for their own benefit.

He says that the Taliban are not fighting the US for ideological reasons, they are fighting because the US Government has put war criminals in charge of the country. He calls upon the Western public to question their governments’ decision to pay the expenses of these war criminals which, Bashardost says, include an army of bodyguards and the living expenses of the warlords’ many wives.

I agree with him. He talks about the origins of democracy, quotes Abraham Lincoln, and talks about human rights violations in Afghanistan. While we are talking a group of Pashtun, and then Uzbek, men arrive. They sit, listening attentively. They seem tribal. I ask where they come from. They are from Faryab. Bashardost says that inside his tent there is a peaceful Afghanistan where all ethnic groups are one. People walking past the tent, on the road, look at us.

Bashardost takes us and shows us his parliamentary office. It’s five minutes drive from his tent. We drive in his old 1991-model car. I, the only woman, sit in front and Bashardost squeezes between my friends at the back. En route, he tells us that he chose his two deputies because of their honesty and dedication; one is a university lecturer and the other a female human rights commissioner.

We spend a few minutes in his office, where he gives us some campaign literature and lets us take pictures with him. He gives us a lift back and gets out of the car to say goodbye to us. Unlike every other Afghan politician he feels secure and has no bodyguards. He says people of Afghanistan ensure his safety and he has never received any threats.

I leave impressed by his honesty, generosity of spirit and solidarity for the poor of the country. But deep down I know he will not win. The reason why he will not win is because Afghans will not vote for one of their own; they will vote for one they can look up to, they will vote for a king not a messiah.

I hope that whoever wins the election takes a few minutes to ponder why some people chose to vote for Bashardost.

***
Zuhra Bahman was born in Kabul Afghanistan where she spent her early years swinging from trees and making snow people. After a stint as a refugee in Pakistan she moved with her family to Northern Afghanistan town of Mazar e Sharef, where she became consciously aware of the beauty of her country and its people.

Back to Top



Other Stories:


Life in Talibanistan - Part One: Throw these infidels in jail
Asia Times (09/03/2010)

The disconnect between pipelines and transparency
Globe and Mail, Canada (09/03/2010)

Of women, cosmetics & electioneering
Pajhwok (09/03/2010)

Karzai orders huge shakeup in Ministry of Interior
Pajhwok (09/03/2010)

Afghan banker warns of 'revolution'
United Press International (09/03/2010)

Karzai tells Afghans not to panic in rush for withdrawals
The Washington Post (09/03/2010)

What Led Kabul To Sack Ambassador To U.S.?
RFE/RL (09/02/2010)

Karzai's brother calls for U.S. to shore up Kabul Bank as withdrawals accelerate
The Washington Post (09/02/2010)

Interviews With Said Jawad, Afghan Ambassador To U.S
CNN, The Situation Room (09/02/2010)

Afghans Pull Money From Weakened Bank
The New York Times (09/02/2010)

Afghan finance minister: "Every penny of the deposits would be guaranteed by the government"
The Associated Press (09/02/2010)

Lessons in Crony Capitalism
The Huffington Post (09/02/2010)

Too Corrupt to Fail?
The New Yorker (09/02/2010)

A.Q. Khan
Newsweek (09/02/2010)

'It's premature to begin pulling troops' from Afghanistan, says Greg Mortenson
Pioneer Press (09/02/2010)

Lonq queues at Afghan bank amid corruption claims
AFP (09/02/2010)

14 Candidates Removed from Parliamentary Elections List
Tolo News (09/02/2010)

Few signs of run on Afghanistan's Kabul Bank
The Associated Press (09/02/2010)

Nervous Afghans pull money from Kabul Bank, raising fears
The Washington Post (09/02/2010)

Afghan ambassador to US to leave post, slams smears
AFP (09/01/2010)

Afghanistan takes over biggest private bank to avert collapse
AFP (09/01/2010)

Karzai in panic as graft probe closes in
Global Post (09/01/2010)

Where Did The Money Go?
Yahoo News (09/01/2010)

Afghanistan's biggest bank in near disastrous collapse
World News (09/01/2010)

After Obama's Iraq Speech, Afghans Worry About U.S. Commitment
TIME (09/01/2010)

Afghan Police's Lack of Guns and Gas Shows U.S. Exit Plan Flaw
Bloomberg (09/01/2010)

"Afghan concern about Pak is legitimate" - Gen. Petraeus
The Associated Press (09/01/2010)

Birthplace of the Taliban: the next battleground
The Associated Press (09/01/2010)

Afghan Ambassador Said T. Jawad leaving his post in Washington
The Washington Post (09/01/2010)

Afghanistan bomb attacks kill twenty-one US soldiers in 48 hours
The Telegraph (09/01/2010)


Back to Top